Jimmy's Pizza Menu (Update 2026)

Jimmy's Pizza offers a diverse menu that caters to all pizza lovers. Start with premium pizzas like the Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza and the BBQ Chicken Pizza, each crafted with fresh ingredients and bursting with flavor. If you're in the mood for something unique, try the Baked Potato Pizza, a local favorite.

Looking for some variety? Customize your meal with a Build Your Own Pizza option, featuring gluten-free and cauliflower crusts. For those who love pasta, the Thursday Specials showcase homemade lasagna and hearty spaghetti. Jimmy's also has plenty of appetizers like Garlic Cheese Toast and Pizza Fries, perfect for sharing (or not)!

Kids have their own menu featuring smaller portions of the classics, while dessert options like Brownie Bites and Dessert Pizza wrap up your meal on a sweet note.

Jimmy's Pizza Menu image 1
Jimmy's Pizza Menu image 2
Jimmy's Pizza Menu image 3
Jimmy's Pizza Menu image 4
Jimmy's Pizza

Jimmy's Pizza Interior, Food, Ambiance

Walking into Jimmy's Pizza reveals a warm and inviting atmosphere, perfect for families, friends, and solo diners alike. The bright, cheerful decor captures the spirit of Hawley, featuring local artwork and photos that evoke a sense of community and belonging. Seating options accommodate everyone, whether it's an intimate dinner or a lively group celebration.

The aroma of freshly baked pizza wafts through the air, teasing your appetite right as you walk through the door. The energy in the restaurant is contagious, with laughter and chatter mixing with the sounds of sizzling pizzas being pulled from the oven.

Staff members are friendly and accommodating, often sharing their favorite menu items to enhance your dining experience.

Jimmy's Pizza not only serves amazing food but also cultivates an atmosphere where everyone feels welcome.

Jimmy's Pizza

About Jimmy's Pizza Food and Specialties

At Jimmy's Pizza, the food reflects a commitment to flavor and creativity. The extensive menu includes 17 options under premium pizzas alone, showcasing how pizza can go beyond the ordinary. Each pie is a work of art, with toppings ranging from classic pepperoni to unique twists like BBQ chicken and buffalo chicken.

Calzones are another highlight, with 18 delicious varieties, including the fan-favorite Bacon Cheeseburger Calzone. For those looking for lighter fare, the salads and well-balanced pasta options, like the Broccoli Alfredo and homemade lasagna, provide satisfying choices that don’t skimp on taste.

This variety keeps diners coming back, making it a mere 10-minute drive for Hawley residents a frequent excursion.

Special events like Monday Pizza Specials and Pasta Thursdays encourage community members to gather, enjoy, and indulge together.

Jimmy's Pizza

Jimmy's Pizza maintains a commitment to quality, flavor, and community involvement. Their specialty lies in offering a wide range of pizza choices that cater to everyone's preferences. With an emphasis on fresh ingredients and bold flavors, each pizza promises a satisfying experience. Beyond pizza, the vision includes expanding menu options to accommodate dietary restrictions, such as gluten-free and cauliflower crusts.

Their dedication extends to community initiatives, partnering with local organizations to give back. More than just a dining destination, Jimmy’s Pizza aims to create lasting relationships within Hawley, making dining here a part of the local culture. Regular events and promotions reflect this vision, fostering a community that comes together over great food and shared experiences.